Church sexual abuse victims’ complaint rejected by European Court
Share article:
Share article:

Church sexual abuse victims’ complaint rejected by European Court

Archive footage of Roman Catholic priest. Credit: Belga

The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) on Thursday rejected complaints made by sexual abuse victims to sue the Vatican over the Church’s handling of the abuse scandals.

The case was brought before the court in Strasbourg by 24 Belgian, French and Dutch nationals, who alleged that they were sexually abused by Catholic priests when they were children.

Previously, a judge in the Ghent Court of First Instance had ruled that the Church was “legally untouchable,” meaning it could not be sued.

Following the ruling of the Belgian court, the alleged victims lodged an application with the European Court of Human Rights on 2 February 2017.

In this instance, they raised the question of the Roman Catholic Church government’s immunity from the jurisdiction of domestic courts by citing the right of access to a court, alleging that by applying this principle, the court prevented the group from pursuing their civil claims, in violation of the European Convention on Human Rights.

However, the ECHR has backed the judgement made by the Belgian court, rejecting claims made by the applicants.

“In today’s Chamber judgment, the Court held, by a majority (six votes to one), that there had been no violation of Article 6 § 1 (right of access to a court) of the European Convention on Human Rights,” an ECHR statement read, referring to the previous trial.

Related News

 

In their original class action, filed in 2011, the complainants demanded €10,000 in compensation from the Holy See – the government of the Roman Catholic Church – as well as several leaders of the Belgian Catholic Church and various Catholic associations regarding the harm caused by the Church’s policy of silence on the issue of sexual abuse.

The case itself started a decade ago, when several testimonies emerged of sexual abuse within the Church’s ranks, resulting in the former bishop of Bruges, Roger Vangheluwe, admitting to sexual abuse and resigning.

As this was a Chamber judgement, both sides are now given three months to request that the case be referred to the Grand Chamber of the ECHR for a final ruling. When a case is referred to this chamber, it does not include any judges who were involved when the case was first examined.

Latest news

Mayor wants to close two Brussels bars where alleged sexual assaults took place
Ixelles' Mayor Christos Doulkeridis (Ecolo) said that he’d like to close the two bars that employed a man accused of raping multiple patrons, ...
‘Untenable’: Mayor says situation at Brussels North station is out of control
The situation at Brussels North Station is no longer tenable, Schaerbeek's mayor Cécile Jodogne (Défi) says. Drug dealing, homelessness, ...
Suicide second-leading cause of death among European youth
Suicide is the number two killer among young people living in Europe, a recent Unicef report on the state of their mental health found. The ...
‘Too little, too late’: Brussels mayors criticise CST implementation
After a two week delay, the Covid Safe Ticket (CST) will become mandatory in several situations in Brussels from today (Friday). Some mayors blame a ...
Sciensano expert warns of rising Covid-19 cases this winter
The return of colder weather and the relaxing of health measures are giving rise to new Covid-19 contaminations and hospitalisations around Belgium, ...
Hospital food is making you sick, Belgian study shows
Eating hospital meals results in a measurable decline in health, according to a report from the Flemish television network VTM, which paints a ...
Belgium in Brief: Supply Issues
There are few things more jarring than walking into a store and finding that the shelves are empty, be that partially or otherwise. One thing ...
Stolen Magritte painting on display for first time in ten years
Surrealist painter René Magritte's work "Olympia", which made headlines across the world when it was stolen from a museum in Belgium in 2009, will be ...
Brussels airport pilots ’15 minute’ PCR test
Brussels Airport has announced that it will soon begin a trial of an ultra-fast PCR test able to detect Covid-19 in 15 minutes, a far faster ...
Over 1,000 demonstrators march in Brussels following sexual assault allegations
Around 1,300 people gathered in Ixelles on Thursday night to march against sexual violence, according to reporting from Bruzz. The march was ...
Covid Safe Ticket mandatory in Brussels, but no fines yet
The Brussels-Capital Region will expand the use of the Covid Safe Ticket (CST) from today (Friday), but it will take a few days before rule-breakers ...
Belgium hosts ‘farewell party’ for Merkel today
Angela Merkel will be in Belgium on Friday for an official visit as a symbolic "farewell" before leaving her position as German Chancellor after 16 ...