Royal Academies: monopoly held by Sciensano has led to incoherences
Share article:
Share article:

Royal Academies: monopoly held by Sciensano has led to incoherences

Spokespersons for Sciensano dominate the news about the virus. © Belga

Since the first appearance of the novel coronavirus and the Covid-19 pandemic, the news in Belgium has been largely filtered through the scientific institute for public health, known as Sciensano.

Now two other august bodies, the Royal Academy of Medicine (ARMB) and the Royal Academy of Sciences, Letters and Fine Arts (ARB) have issued a statement accusing Sciensano of exercising a “monopoly” over public policy, and of making “arbitrary and opaque decisions” on policy.

The arrival of the crisis, the academies say, led to a reaction of urgency and improvisation, despite the new virus and its effects having been known in Wuhan in China for two months previously.

Despite the forewarning, however, the disease arrived in Belgium to find the country lacking any prepared and suitable plan for tackling it. And, the two academies go on, there is now still not “a solid plan which would allow Belgium to face a second wave of contamination or even the appearance of a pandemic of another type”.

So far, we have had to think in the short term,” writes Professor Jean-Michel Foidart, permanent secretary of the ARMB. “Today, we must also work on the medium and long term. Some decisions taken in recent weeks have been taken despite international scientific recommendations. Our two Academies are politically independent, which is a guarantee of transparency and consistency for the population.”

Belgium was not well-prepared to deal with this pandemic, Prof Foidart goes on, “It is essential that this does not happen again. We are in a race against the clock, Belgium cannot afford to neglect the skills of the Academicians.”

Now that the daily numbers are dwindling, and the country has entered the test-trace-isolate phase of the pandemic, the academies are demanding “that a series of decisions that put our country in danger and on the sidelines of what the international health authorities advocate, be clarified and reviewed.”

Those include the policy of testing.

The policy applied to rapid serological tests is incoherent: despite an order for one million rapid tests, the use and reimbursement of these remain prohibited on our territory. There is also an urgent need to reassess the criteria for the ordering and reimbursement of other forms of serology. Finally, the epidemiological studies essential to monitor the rate of penetration of the virus are unreliable as things stand, because they are the result of local initiatives and are therefore not coordinated.”

Ultimately, the statement says, the confusion and incoherences of the decisions made on the basis of Sciensano advice have led to a loss of confidence and a sort of defiance on the part of the public.

At these crucial moments to the control of the transmission of SARS-CoV-2, it is vital to re-establish confidence and credibility between the decision-making bodies and civil society,” the statement concludes.

At the time of publication, Sciensano had not yet responded to the criticism of the academies.

Alan Hope
The Brussels Times

Latest news

Cigarette-eating robot patrols Ghent streets to fight littering
A litter fighting (and eating) robot will be patrolling the streets of Ghent in the coming weeks in an effort to raise awareness of the growing ...
Brussels Airport becomes shareholder in SkeyDrone
The Brussels Airport company has signed an agreement to become a 50 percent shareholder in SkeyDrone, a subsidiary of skeyes, the Belgian Air ...
Two former Belgian top executives plead guilty to bid manipulation in the US
Two former Belgian top executives of the security company G4S have pleaded guilty in the US to bid rigging, according to reporting from De Tijd. ...
8 arrested in Belgium and Luxembourg for fraud and social dumping
On Tuesday, around 80 police investigators and 26 social investigators made a series of simultaneous arrests in Belgium, Italy and Luxembourg as part ...
More than 5,500 people took part in the citizens’ consultation on road safety
Over 5,500 people took part in a citizens’ consultation on road safety for Belgium between July and October, according to Belga News Agency. The ...
Coronavirus: Nearly 1,000 patients hospitalised, 80 admissions a day on average
Between October 10 and 16, an average of 3,151 people were infected with Covid-19 every day, according to figures from the Sciensano Public Health ...
‘More concern and false impressions’: colds are not worse than before, experts say
While it seems like cold viruses are hitting especially hard this autumn, with more severe and longer-lasting symptoms, doctors are saying that this ...
More women take police selection tests in Belgium
The selection tests to become a police inspector have more and more female participants, according to figures released by Interior Affairs Minister ...
‘Absurd’: all Brussels schools should have the same Covid rules
Several city councillors for education in Brussels are calling to abolish the "absurd" differences in coronavirus measures for Dutch-speaking and ...
Massive renovations for iconic venue in the heart of Brussels
Brussels concert hall Ancienne Belgique has announced plans to renovate the AB Café and the AB Salon and is looking for a contractor fit for the job. ...
Display of child’s room in Brussels raises awareness of foster families
An exhibit that features a fictitious child’s bedroom has been on display since Tuesday at the Place d'Armes in Namur, with the support of the ...
Test results show pupils have fallen behind in Flemish schools
Learning delays have been reported in almost all subject areas in Flanders since the start of the pandemic, a trend that continued in 2021, a ...