Share article:
Share article:

Calls to end systematic strip searches in Belgian prisons

© Belga

Belgium’s Federal Ombudsman has called on prisons to stop systematic strip searches of inmates to strike a better balance between security and dignity.

“We are calling on all prisons to stop systematic strip searches immediately,” Federal Ombudsman Catherine De Bruecker said in a report issued on Monday. “Before each strip search, prisons must assess whether it is necessary, based in particular on the detainee’s profile. Stripping people to search them must be an absolute exception.”

The Ombudsman called for “solutions to be found for the problems observed to ensure, in the final analysis, a better balance between prison security and detainees’ dignity.”

All Belgian prisons systematically subject detainees to strip searches, even though they are prohibited by law. Generally, these searches are not conducted in the best of conditions and, in some circumstances, they could clearly be avoided, according to the report of an investigation that was scheduled to be submitted to Parliament on Monday by the Ombudsman, an independent institution that looks into citizens’ complaints against federal institutions.

Detainees had complained to the Ombudsman about the way they were strip searched. The searches, hated by detainees because of their humiliating nature, also increased the tensions in prisons. The Ombudsman thus carried out the investigation, into the organisation of the searches in Belgium’s prisons, and published her report on Monday. The penitentiary administration has already indicated that it wishes to incorporate the report’s 37 recommendations into its new security policy.

One of the findings of the report is that systematic strip searches are still being conducted in Belgian prisons even though they are illegal. “Prisons do not check to see whether these searches are really necessary, and they do not take detainees’ profile, whether they are high-risk or not, into account,” the federal mediator found. “In some prisons, detainees who work are subjected to many searches each day, reaching, at times, an intolerable degree of humiliation.”

Moreover, the regulations related to strip searches contain a certain number of guarantees aimed at avoiding abuses, but they are often circumvented. The investigation showed, for example, that a large number of searches are conducted without any prior autorisation.

“Management signs after the fact, as a formality, but the vast majority of decisions are motivated in a stereotypical manner and fail to mention any concrete clue that may justify the search,” the report added.

“The investigation nevertheless highlighted good practices allowing these risks to be limited and better ensuring a balance between prison security and detainees’ dignity,” it noted.

Finally, prisons do not always assess the need for and proportionality of searches to respond to the risk they need to overcome, and some searches could clearly be avoided.

“Generally speaking, the search method is not correctly applied,” the Ombudsman said. “Some prisons still use techniques that were given up because of their humiliating nature.”

The Brussels Times

Latest news

Eating less meat won’t actually help much with Flemish CO2 emissions
When it comes to the ways in which ordinary people can help to reduce CO2 emissions, eating less meat is often touted as an important solution. ...
At least one in seven coronavirus patients suffers from long-term Covid
Six months after becoming infected with the coronavirus, at least one in seven people still show symptoms connected to the infection, varying from ...
Operation Sky ECC: Major arrests and another large scale operation
A major operation took place last night in Belgium as a result of Operation Sky ECC, the name given to an investigation into organised crime that ...
Consultative Committee expected to discuss telework and state of emergency
On Tuesday afternoon, Belgium's Consultative Committee will be meeting earlier than expected to discuss the worsening epidemiological situation. ...
Highest number of new Covid-19 cases recorded since November 2020
The number of people testing positive for the coronavirus in Belgium is continuing to increase and has now reached levels last recorded in November ...
Prototype test plane crashes in Belgium after pilot ejects
A prototype aircraft crashed on Sunday afternoon in Yves-Gomezée (Walcourt, Namur province) during a test flight, according to several local media ...
EU questions Israeli decision to ban Palestinian NGOs
The Israeli government’s decision on Friday to outlaw six Palestinian civil society organisations operating in the West Bank has caused consternation ...
Gare Maritime: Brussels’ most exciting new architectural project
A generation ago, the Gare Maritime in the Tour & Taxis industrial site was an abandoned wasteland. It is now a model for urban renewal and ...
More politicians than ordinary citizens at the Conference on the Future of Europe
The second Plenary of the Conference took place on Saturday in the European Parliament in Strasbourg and discussed the contributions from the ...
Belgium’s Consultative Committee will meet today
The next meeting of Belgium's Consultative Committee, scheduled for Friday, has been brought forward to Tuesday at 4:30 PM, according to local media ...
Coca-Cola, Pepsi and Unilever are world’s biggest plastic polluters
Coca-Cola, Pepsi, and Unilever were found to be the world's biggest polluters of plastic in a report published by Branded on Monday. Over 11,000 ...
Four men charged with illegally buying thousands of live ducks to hunt on private land
Four Belgian men will appear in court on Monday facing charges related to the purchase of thousands of ducks, which were then released into a private ...