Infrabel will appeal against judgement on Buizingen train crash
Share article:
Share article:

Infrabel will appeal against judgement on Buizingen train crash

Rescuers face the wreckage of the trains on the morning of the accident © Belga

The rail infrastructure company Infrabel has announced it will appeal the ruling of a court in the case of the fatal train crash at Buizingen in Flemish Brabant in February 2010, in which 19 people died and 310 were injured. The company issued an announcement in which it described the decision to appeal as “tough and difficult”.

The accident happened when a stop train riding from Leuven to Halle ran into an intercity train travelling in the opposite direction on the same track from Quiévrain to Liege, close to Buizingen station. Rescue services arrived at the scene rapidly, but they had to work in severe wreckage as well as cold and snow on the tracks.

Nearly ten years after the crash, on 3 December this year, a court ruled that the fault in the accident was firstly that of the driver of the Leuven train, which passed through a red light. But the major fault lay, the court said, with the rail authority SNCB and with Infrabel, because of technical failures that contributed to the accident. Both were ordered to pay a fine of €550,000, half of that sum suspended in the case of Infrabel.

At the time of that judgement, families of the dead and injured told De Standaard they expected the two companies to accept their responsibility and not to appeal the judgement. “That would be a new slap in the face for the grieving families, the survivors and their loved ones,” one relative told the paper. “It would show a lack of respect for everyone who has in one way or another been affected by this disaster.”

In a statement issued by Infrabel today, however, the company makes it clear it is less concerned about the judgement itself than about the judge’s statement which motivates the judgement.

Unfortunately the content of the ruling would have severe consequences for the normal exercise of our duties, if we were to apply its terms,” the statement says. “To implement the ruling would lead among other things to the scrapping of a large number of trains. For that reason we find ourselves, on the advice of our lawyers and after a thorough analysis of the situation, obliged to lodge an appeal against this ruling.”

Concretely, Infrabel claims, to follow the ruling to the letter would be to put in jeopardy the proper functioning of the rail network. To take one concrete example, the ruling calls for a maximum of trains passing through the notorious North-South connection in Brussels to be held to 400 a day, counting in both directions. In reality, at the moment, the traffic amounts to 1,200 trains a day in that one connection between the North station and Midi station, passing through the Central station.

In another section of the ruling, the court calls on Infrabel, in cases where trains are due to cross, to place all points concerned in an alert position, ready to respond rapidly in case of human error. The company responds:
“If we should adhere to the ruling, it would mean that we had to put 80% of the points in our network in protective position. For that to be applied everywhere, the rail network would have to be completely redesigned and train traffic thoroughly reorganised, with all the consequences that would imply for rail customers and for mobility in Belgium.”

The company’s statement anticipates a negative reaction from the civil parties in the case. “We certainly do not wish to evade our responsibility with this decision, and it certainly is not a sign of any lack of respect for the victims. And this procedure will have no effect whatsoever on the damages due to the victims.”

The legal procedure to determine what damages are due to victims and their relatives, and who should pay, is due to start in June next year.

Alan Hope
The Brussels Times

Latest news

Belgium in Brief: A Consultative Committee Sequel
Sequels often have a lot to live up to and when it comes to movie franchises, it gets difficult to keep up the hype once you get towards the final ...
25 years ago today: 300,000 people marched in white against child abuse
On this day 25 years ago, over 300,000 people marched in Brussels to demand a more effective justice system and to support the families of Julie, ...
Windy weather forecast should lower gas prices
After weeks of relatively calm conditions, a return to windy weather should lower Europe's soaring energy prices. Wind turbines in the UK and Germany ...
EC calls on candidate countries to focus on fundamental reforms before they can join the EU
The Commission adopted yesterday its 2021 Enlargement Package, providing a detailed assessment of the state of play and the progress made by the ...
Cigarette-eating robot patrols Ghent streets to fight littering
A litter fighting (and eating) robot will be patrolling the streets of Ghent in the coming weeks in an effort to raise awareness of the growing ...
Display of child’s room in Brussels raises awareness of foster families
An exhibit that features a fictitious child’s bedroom has been on display since Tuesday at the Place d'Armes in Namur, with the support of the ...
Brussels Airport becomes shareholder in SkeyDrone
The Brussels Airport company has signed an agreement to become a 50 percent shareholder in SkeyDrone, a subsidiary of skeyes, the Belgian Air ...
Two former Belgian top executives plead guilty to bid manipulation in the US
Two former Belgian top executives of the security company G4S have pleaded guilty in the US to bid rigging, according to reporting from De Tijd. ...
8 arrested in Belgium and Luxembourg for fraud and social dumping
On Tuesday, around 80 police investigators and 26 social investigators made a series of simultaneous arrests in Belgium, Italy and Luxembourg as part ...
More than 5,500 people took part in the citizens’ consultation on road safety
Over 5,500 people took part in a citizens’ consultation on road safety for Belgium between July and October, according to Belga News Agency. The ...
Coronavirus: Nearly 1,000 patients hospitalised, 80 admissions a day on average
Between October 10 and 16, an average of 3,151 people were infected with Covid-19 every day, according to figures from the Sciensano Public Health ...
‘More concern and false impressions’: colds are not worse than before, experts say
While it seems like cold viruses are hitting especially hard this autumn, with more severe and longer-lasting symptoms, doctors are saying that this ...