Making school students repeat a year is useless, even dangerous say experts
Share article:
Share article:

Making school students repeat a year is useless, even dangerous say experts

© Pxhere
Stock photo
© Pxhere

Forcing school students to repeat a year is “often a remedy worse than the illness it sets out to treat,” according to a new study carried out by the universities of Liege and Louvain-la-Neuve. According to the study (PDF, in French), in the French community of Belgium more than 60% of pupils in the fifth year of secondary school have already repeated at least one year, and half of them twice.

Education is a matter for the language communities rather than the regional governments: there are both Dutch- and French-speaking schools in Brussels, for example.

Using another metric, the study reports that 46% of pupils at French community schools are behind in their education at the age of 15. Only eight countries in the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) have a figure above 20%, and the figure for French-speaking Belgium is the highest of all. The average for the whole OECD is 12%.

The French-speaking figure is a good deal higher than the score for the other language communities: 30% for the German community and 24% for the Flemish community.

The conventional wisdom has it that repeating a year allows a pupil a chance to catch up and improve their performance. The study suggests the practice does no such thing: in fact it not only emphasises social and cultural disadvantages, but also leads to the student losing self-confidence and perseverance – which the report identifies as crucial to education success – leading to an increased risk of truancy and exclusion.

“The researchers would not pretend that automatic advancement [to an upper year] offers a solution to the multiple difficulties students can have,” the report concludes. “But they stress that repeating is often a remedy worse than the illness it sets out to treat.” In the words of the title of the paper itself: “Repeating a year is ineffective, socially unjust and leads to students dropping out.”

Continuing the medical metaphor: “If doubling were a medicine, it would be banned, because it has failed to demonstrate any benefits, and is frequently accompanied by negative side-effects. If we wish to reduce the inequalities which undermine our school system and support students in difficulty, it is time to change the prescription.”

Alan Hope
The Brussels Times

Latest news

Heirs of Michael Jackson demand that Belgian radio show ‘King of Pop’ changes name
The heirs of American pop singer Michael Jackson have demanded that a Belgian radio programme, called "King of Pop" changes its name, their lawyers ...
More than one billion coronavirus vaccines exported by EU
The European Union (EU) has exported more than one billion coronavirus vaccines globally over the past ten months, of which just under one-tenth was ...
SNCB brings free little libraries to stations
The Belgian railway company SNCB is adding free little libraries to its stations. The “book boxes,” as they’re called, allow passengers to grab a ...
Belgium in Brief: What Is Bouncing Back?
What do you think of when you think of a country "bouncing back" after a crisis?  Cambridge Dictionary says it is "to start to be successful again ...
Café patron stabs manager after being asked to see proof of vaccination
A customer stabbed a café manager in Brussels on Saturday after being asked to show his Covid Safe Ticket (CST), according to Bruzz. Asking to see ...
Belgium to simplify administrative processes with ‘digital wallet’
The federal government wants to create an online "wallet" for all people living in Belgium which would bundle all official documents, from visas to ...
‘Start of infection wave’: Flanders to turn red on European map again
Flanders will turn red on the map of the European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control (ECDC) again this week, as the daily average of new ...
Staff strike at application centre for asylum seekers
The staff of an application centre for asylum seekers in Brussels began a 24-strike on Monday morning, meaning that no one can apply for asylum there ...
Bpost plans to merge parcel and letter services in Belgium
The new CEO of Bpost – Belgium's primary mail delivery company and one of the country's largest civilian employers – has decided to merge the ...
Belgian playground bullying drama wins at London Film Festival
Playground (original title 'Un Monde'), the first feature film by Belgian director Laura Wandel, was awarded the top prize in the First Feature ...
Will Brussels bounce back?
The lockdowns have tested the city and forced it to confront key questions about its future. Derek Blyth looks back at an extraordinary moment in our ...
Brussels launches initiatives to improve cyclist and pedestrian safety
Two new initiatives are being developed in Brussels to make the city safer and more pedestrian and cyclist-friendly, especially around key areas on ...