Share article:
Share article:

Apple accused of breaking rules on music streaming apps

© Gph Rhy Yan for Unsplash

The European Commission has sent tech giant Apple an official statement of objections relating to the company’s alleged breach of competition rules in how it deals with music streaming apps in the App Store.

Apple has its own music streaming service, but the problem revolves around the App Store, where third parties make their own apps available. The Commission describes the App Store as “the sole gateway to consumers using Apple’s smart mobile devices running on Apple’s smart mobile operating system iOS. Apple’s devices and software form a “closed ecosystem” in which Apple controls every aspect of the user experience for iPhones and iPads.”

Users of Apple devices can only use the App Store, imposing restrictions not only on users, but also on companies wanting to get their apps to the users. In theory, Apple allows competitors to list their products on the App Store, but in reality, the Commission found, developers are subject to Apple’s “mandatory and non-negotiable rules”.

Among those rules is the obligatory use of Apple’s own in-app purchase system for subscriptions, on which Apple charges a 30% fee. Streaming providers usually pass that fee on to customers, which makes their products more expensive.

Secondly, developers are strictly forbidden from informing app users of the possibility of buying music subscriptions outside of the Apple ecosystem, where the cost is usually lower not least because the 30% fee is not paid.

App stores play a central role in today’s digital economy. We can now do our shopping, access news, music or movies via apps instead of visiting websites,” said Margrethe Vestager, commissioner for competition policy.

Our preliminary finding is that Apple is a gatekeeper to users of iPhones and iPads via the App Store. With Apple Music, Apple also competes with music streaming providers. By setting strict rules on the App Store that disadvantage competing music streaming services, Apple deprives users of cheaper music streaming choices and distorts competition.”

The statement of objections is only the first step in the antitrust process. The parties, in this case Apple, can examine the documents the Commission has, and request a hearing to present their case.

Sending a Statement of Objections and opening of a formal antitrust investigation does not prejudge the outcome of the investigations,” the Commission said.

Latest news

How a clever cycling network brings bikers to Flanders
Belgium has always had a special relationship with cycling, but a clever Flemish system of route nodes makes it easier than ever. As Daniela De ...
Brexit fishing conflict escalates: France to adopt retaliatory measures
The conflict between France and the UK over fishing licences post-Brexit continues to escalate. France is set to adopt retaliatory measures ...
Mandatory from Monday: the new rules for Belgium’s Covid Safe Ticket
From Monday 1 November, presenting the Covid Safe Ticket (CST) will become mandatory in all hospitality businesses and fitness centres throughout ...
Car falls off opening bridge in Leuven, parents and child slightly injured
On Wednesday afternoon, a young family experienced the fright of their lives in Leuven when the bridge across the Vaartkom that they were driving on ...
Brussels and Wallonia once again dark red on European travel map
The Brussels-Capital Region and Wallonia have turned dark red in the latest update to the travel map by the European Centre for Disease Prevention ...
Belgium in Brief: What Now?
We've had the meeting, we know the results, and now the time has come to see what happens next. So I find myself wondering a simple question: ...
Floating solar farm to be built along Ostend coast next year
Dutch company Oceans of Energy has announced plans to construct a solar farm off the coast of Ostend next year that should eventually provide enough ...
Trial against Deliveroo begins in Brussels
The Labour Court of Brussels will hear a case on Thursday involving 27 couriers for Deliveroo, who are suing the platform for precarious working ...
Belgium switches to winter time this weekend (yes, again)
This weekend, Belgium will once again change the clocks from summer to winter time, meaning that at 3:00 AM, the clocks will go back one hour, ...
Turkey gets green light to join EU schemes, UK still waiting
On Wednesday, Turkey was given the go-ahead to join the EU’s flagship research, education and youth programmes while the United Kingdom’s bid to stay ...
‘Too much, too quickly’: 40% of burnout patients given antidepressants
The process of diagnosing burnout among people in Belgium is too slow, while too many antidepressants are being prescribed too quickly to people ...
Travel confidence: 2 in 3 Europeans plan to travel in the next six months
Demand for travel is strong across Europe despite the end of the peak summer season, with 2 in 3 Europeans planning to travel in the next six months. ...