Share article:
Share article:

EU and UK on Brexit collision course?


This week has seen EU and UK clarifying their positions on how to solve the outstanding issues in the withdrawal agreement after the negotiators made some progress last December in the first phase of the negotiations. EU presented a 100 pages long draft withdrawal agreement on Wednesday which translates the joint report from the negotiators into legal terms. One important issue is a protocol on how to avoid a hard border on Ireland.

“If the UK has better ideas on how to avoid a hard border while preserving the integrity of the Single Market, we are ready to look at them in a constructive way,” EU chief negotiator Michel Barnier said this week.

His British counterpart, David Davis, responded that “nothing is agreed until everything is agreed.”

On free movement, the EU’s position is that all EU citizens arriving in the UK during the transition period should have exactly the same rights as EU citizens who arrived before the UK’s withdrawal.

During the transition period, which EU keeps reminding has been requested by UK, British citizens and businesses will continue to have the same rights and the same obligations as they have today up until the end of 2020. But the UK will no longer take part in EU’s decision‑making process.

Ahead of Prime-Minister Theresa May’s speech today, Barnier said that “any vision of the future must take into account the fact that the EU cannot and will not compromise on its founding principles.”

“UK is closing the doors on itself, one by one, and the only possible model that remains is that of a free trade agreement,” he said. But that seemed to be ruled out by May in her speech today afternoon (2 February).

The British Prime-Minister underlined that the agreement with the EU must respect the referendum. “It was a vote to take control of our borders, laws and money.”

She sounded optimistic: “We are close to agreement on the terms of an implementation period which was a key element of December’s deal. Of course some points of difference remain – but I am confident these can be resolved in the days ahead.”

On Ireland, she said that “We have been clear all along that we don’t want to go back to a hard border in Ireland. We have ruled out any physical infrastructure at the border, or any related checks and controls.”

While rejecting the Norway and Canada models for economic partnerships and trade with the EU, or trade on World Trade Organisation terms, she envisaged a “deep and comprehensive agreement with the EU.”

“I want the broadest and deepest possible partnership – covering more sectors and co-operating more fully than any Free Trade Agreement anywhere in the world today,” she said.

Barnier tweeted diplomatically that he welcomed May’s speech. “Clarity about UK leaving single market and customs union, and recognition of trade-offs will inform European Council guidelines re: future free trade agreement.”

But other reactions were more critical implying that UK cannot both have the cake and eat it.

Tony Blair, UK’s former prime minister, set out his solutions for the Brexit dilemma during a speech on 1 February arranged by the European Policy Centre (EPC) in Brussels. EU and UK should stop talking past each other, he said.

Blair described the dilemma of the negotiation as either being close to Europe to avoid economic damage but therefore accepting its rules or being free from Europe’s rules but therefore accepting economic damage.

He complained about the lack of leadership in UK and called for a second referendum in which the British people would reject Brexit. 

A second referendum would be based on the assumption that UK would return to a reformed EU which would be different than the EU which UK voted to leave in the first referendum. In particular he suggested that “a comprehensive plan on immigration control” would be key in convincing pro-Brexit Britons to vote differently in a second referendum.

“People will say it can’t happen,” Tony Blair said. “To which I say in these times in politics anything can happen.”

But reforming EU will take time and there is hardly time for that to happen before Brexit next year. EPC Chief Executive Fabian Zuleeg, who moderated the debate, didn’t believe in the possibility: “The only alternative to hard Brexit is no Brexit, but clearly time is running out now.”

The Brussels Times

Latest news

More politicians than ordinary citizens at the Conference on the Future of Europe
The second Plenary of the Conference took place on Saturday in the European Parliament in Strasbourg and discussed the contributions from the ...
Belgium’s Consultative Committee to meet on Tuesday
The next meeting of Belgium's Consultative Committee, scheduled for Friday, has been brought forward to Tuesday at 4:30 PM, according to local media ...
Coca-Cola, Pepsi and Unilever are world’s biggest plastic polluters
Coca-Cola, Pepsi, and Unilever were found to be the world's biggest polluters of plastic in a report published by Branded on Monday. Over 11,000 ...
Four men charged with illegally buying thousands of live ducks to hunt on private land
Four Belgian men will appear in court on Monday facing charges related to the purchase of thousands of ducks, which were then released into a private ...
More wolf attacks: 15 deer killed at family resort over the weekend
Fifteen deer were killed by wolves in the Belgian province of Limburg this weekend, between Saturday night and Sunday morning. The deer were ...
Cost of breast cancer still too high for many patients
Breast cancer still carries too high a cost for patients when one in nine women in Belgium will face the disease before reaching 75, according to a ...
Gare Maritime: Brussels’ most exciting new architectural project
A generation ago, the Gare Maritime in the Tour & Taxis industrial site was an abandoned wasteland. It is now a model for urban renewal and ...
Belgium in Brief: Rules For A Fourth Wave
It's the news that nobody wants to hear, but here we go again. Belgium’s council of ministers will hold an emergency meeting on Monday to discuss ...
Belgian grandparents to walk across Scotland for COP26
A group of Belgian grandparents has set off on a 100 km hike that will take them from Belgium to the Scottish city of Glasgow, just ahead of the ...
Rise in fuel prices will bring Belgian State €547 million in tax, say Workers Party
The sharp rise in fuel prices that have been felt across the continent will bring an additional €547 million to the Belgian State, the Workers' Party ...
Amid backlash, Brussels police chief promises to do better for sexual assault victims
After multiple rallies against sexual violence took place in Brussels last week, with victims offering testimony of poor treatment from police when ...
Person hit by train in Brussels
A person was hit by a train in the tunnel between Brussels North and Brussels Central at around 10:20 AM on Monday, railway network manager Infrabel ...