Share article:
Share article:

Coronavirus: EU’s strategy for containing the virus

The coronavirus is spreading to more EU member states. On Thursday it had reached about 15 countries, with 12 deaths in Italy and two in France.

The EU agency for disease control (ECDC) has warned for a medium to high risk for the spread of similar clusters as in Italy to the rest of the EU.

Overall, the risk for infection for people in the EU was considered a low to medium but the situation is evolving and an updated risk assessment is awaited to reflect the findings of ECDC’s still on-going mission to Italy.

To contain the spread, screenings and quarantine measures have already been put in place by some countries. The possibility of border controls has been raised for the first time. Mass gatherings, such as sports and music events, might be banned in the near future. It is important for member states to coordinate their measures as regards mass gatherings and to discuss them in advance.

All options were mentioned on Thursday at a technical briefing in Brussels with senior officials from the European Commission and ECDC.

ECDC or the European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control plays a crucial role in the efforts to contain the coronavirus. Set up in 2005 and located in Stockholm, it has put in place a system, based on legal decisions adopted by the EU, for the surveillance of communicable diseases and the rapid detection and response.

Risk assessments are done by a group of ECDC experts and produced at the request of the Commission, a member state or following an internal decision. A small group of experts meet also daily to assess the situation. An in-depth assessment is done every two weeks.

Rapid response to serious cross-border threats to health is coordinated at EU level within the Health Security Committee, composed of representatives of all member states and ECDC.

The Commission, in collaboration with ECDC, announced today that it shortly will issue standardised travel guidance templates to member states to use to provide information on prevention and what to do in case of infection or symptoms for travellers going to and returning from risk areas. The Commission has already issued travel guidance for its own staff.

At the meeting, a warning was voiced against comparing the outbreak of the coronavirus with other diseases such as pneumonia and influenza with relatively high death rates. While there is antibiotic treatment of these diseases, there is no vaccine yet against the coronavirus and it has the potential to infect more people. “We don’t know how far the coronavirus will spread.”

Partly conflicting messages were given as to whether EU wide travel bans or restrictions are covered by EU legislation. Any public health threats must be discussed by a community network established by ECDC for surveillance and control of communicable diseases. “We don’t give advice on border controls but look at the options.”

It would anyway be problematic to entrust health checks to border guards and they would have to cooperate with ECDC’s network.

Containment measures

The Commission differentiates between EU’s external borders and the internal borders between member states. For the external borders, public health threats can be invoked for controls provided that they pass the proportionality test. A member state would also have to coordinate such a measure with its neighbouring countries.

This possibility is not explicitly mentioned in the Schengen borders code which governs the movement of persons across the internal borders. That said, the Commission does not legally exclude member states from imposing internal border controls for public health reasons. Border controls have been imposed by some member states to stem the flow of illegal migrants.

Border controls on public health grounds have apparently never been done in the past and for the moment no member state has notified the Commission that they intend to do so. If they would, the Commission will issue an opinion but it has no right to veto the decision by a member state.

Asked by The Brussels Times about the notification period of four weeks, a senior Commission official admitted that the legal deadline was too long and apparently does not need to be respected in the current evolving situation.

The Commission seems to imply that there is no point in border controls since the virus does not stop at borders. “Refusal of entry would be no appropriate response.” The overriding concern of the Commission, even in the current crisis, is to preserve the integrity of the Schengen area with its open borders.

If infected people should not be banned from crossing internal borders, what should be done instead? In an act of mutual solidarity, member states need to cooperate on quarantine measures. Resources are limited and ECDC doubts that quarantine measures will play a dominant role in the containment of the coronavirus.

An expert said that it was impossible to know if quarantine measures for passengers from China and other affected countries would have made a difference and prevented the outbreak in Europe.

ECDC is working on assisting the member states on improving the quality of screenings of passengers at so-called points of entry (airports, land borders and harbours). Screenings however are not very effective because infected people with no symptoms will not be detected. Is was not clear whether screenings are recommended to detect the up to 25 % of infected persons who do show symptoms.

The advice given at the meeting was that information should be handed out to passengers on how they could protect themselves by simple means or stay at home in self-quarantine.

M. Apelblat
The Brussels Times

Latest news

Belgium in Brief: A Consultative Committee Sequel
Sequels often have a lot to live up to and when it comes to movie franchises, it gets difficult to keep up the hype once you get towards the final ...
25 years ago today: 300,000 people marched in white against child abuse
On this day 25 years ago, over 300,000 people marched in Brussels to demand a more effective justice system and to support the families of Julie, ...
Windy weather forecast should lower gas prices
After weeks of relatively calm conditions, a return to windy weather should lower Europe's soaring energy prices. Wind turbines in the UK and Germany ...
EC calls on candidate countries to focus on fundamental reforms before they can join the EU
The Commission adopted yesterday its 2021 Enlargement Package, providing a detailed assessment of the state of play and the progress made by the ...
Cigarette-eating robot patrols Ghent streets to fight littering
A litter fighting (and eating) robot will be patrolling the streets of Ghent in the coming weeks in an effort to raise awareness of the growing ...
Display of child’s room in Brussels raises awareness of foster families
An exhibit that features a fictitious child’s bedroom has been on display since Tuesday at the Place d'Armes in Namur, with the support of the ...
Brussels Airport becomes shareholder in SkeyDrone
The Brussels Airport company has signed an agreement to become a 50 percent shareholder in SkeyDrone, a subsidiary of skeyes, the Belgian Air ...
Two former Belgian top executives plead guilty to bid manipulation in the US
Two former Belgian top executives of the security company G4S have pleaded guilty in the US to bid rigging, according to reporting from De Tijd. ...
8 arrested in Belgium and Luxembourg for fraud and social dumping
On Tuesday, around 80 police investigators and 26 social investigators made a series of simultaneous arrests in Belgium, Italy and Luxembourg as part ...
More than 5,500 people took part in the citizens’ consultation on road safety
Over 5,500 people took part in a citizens’ consultation on road safety for Belgium between July and October, according to Belga News Agency. The ...
Coronavirus: Nearly 1,000 patients hospitalised, 80 admissions a day on average
Between October 10 and 16, an average of 3,151 people were infected with Covid-19 every day, according to figures from the Sciensano Public Health ...
‘More concern and false impressions’: colds are not worse than before, experts say
While it seems like cold viruses are hitting especially hard this autumn, with more severe and longer-lasting symptoms, doctors are saying that this ...