Share article:
Share article:

Mask obligation ‘unconstitutional,’ says Brussels court

Home affairs minister Annelies Verlinden. © Belga

A police court magistrate in Brussels has acquitted a man charged with failing to wear a face mask, arguing that the obligation to do so is unconstitutional.

Cases before the police court are restricted to minor charges, including traffic offences, and in this case the obligation throughout the Brussels region to wear a face mask at all times in public.

But the magistrate in question declared the blanket obligation to be a breach of the constitutional right to freedom of movement. According to the judgement, that right can only be curtailed on the basis of a law passed by parliament, and not on the basis of a ministerial decree, as is the case with the regulations on Covid-19.

In fact, that has been the case since the beginning of the pandemic. The government passes a set of rules on the authority of the King, but without going through the steps to obtain the approval of parliament.

The executive, according to that pattern, legislates without the authority – or with only the tacit authority – of the legislature.

This is not the first time the constitutional basis for Covid-19 rules has been questioned in court. A court in Charleroi in October struck down corona fines as unlawful, pointing out that the justification for the measure – the protection of public health – does not excuse the means used to achieve it.

The Brussels court of appeal has also found fault with the procedure. However the Council of State, the last word on such matters, has given a guarded approval to the procedure for the time being.

On the question of a proper legislative instrument by which to bring in laws for the protection against Covid-19, the government’s reply is that a so-called ‘pandemic law’ is in preparation.

That law, which is being guided through the procedure by federal home affairs minister Annelies Verlinden (CD&V), is intended to be a compendium of all the areas where legislation would be needed in a pandemic, as well as provisions for those matters which cannot yet be predicted. So it is no surprise that the task is monumental.

Last week Verlinden said she had a draft of the law ready, but that only signifies the bill is still in its very early stages. And already, cracks are beginning to appear.

In a parliamentary response to a question from N-VA member Sophie De Wit, justice minister Vincent Van Quickenborne said the new law was not intended for application to the current crisis.

Just this week, Verlinden said the opposite. “The intention is still to apply this law to the current pandemic,” she said.

UPDATE: This lunchtime, the Brussels prosecutor’s office said it would appeal the ruling of the police court.

“The prosecution would also like to point out that prosecutions for non-compliance with the wearing of face masks will continue to occur as long as no settled and definitive case law would jeopardise the validity of the prosecutions,” the statement said.

Alan Hope
The Brussels Times

Latest news

EU decides to activate emergency brake against new COVID-variant but stops short of flight ban
The new COVID variant detected in South Africa has put the EU on alert and prompted the Council’s Integrated Political Crisis Response (IPCR) to ...
Belgium imposes entry ban on travellers from southern Africa
Belgium is introducing an entry ban for travellers from several countries in the south of Africa following concerns about a new variant (B.1.1.529) ...
Cheat Sheet: New Rules, Quiet December Nights
It's been a while since we've had measures complicated enough to deserve a cheat sheet, but less than a week after Belgium rolled out new measures, ...
Belgium records highest number of new cases since start of pandemic
An average of 16,762 infections per day is now recorded in Belgium, with an absolute record of more than 25,000 infections in one day last Monday, ...
Brexit: trade and travel disrupted as French fishermen blockade ports and Eurotunnel
On Friday, the national committee for the French fishing industry has coordinated a blockade of three French ports as well as lorries bearing freight ...
Belgium implements ‘package of strict measures’
Not even a week after the previous measures came into force, Belgium is taking stricter measures to stop the fourth wave in the country, announced ...
Even with strong action now, ‘we will still have a few weeks of misery,’ says Vlieghe
Even if the Consultative Committee takes powerful and clear decisions today, Belgium will still have to endure a few weeks of misery while the number ...
Brussels tunnels blocked by Uber driver protest
Several tunnels in the centre of Brussels were blocked on Friday morning by Uber drivers protesting against a ruling by the Brussels Court of Appeal ...
Police strikes at Brussels and Charleroi airports cause delays
Police unions are taking action at Brussels and Charleroi airports this Friday morning, causing delayed services at both locations. At 7:00 AM at ...
Black Friday not your bag? Try Green Friday
Today is Black Friday: a North American custom that has made its way across the Atlantic and is when retailers aim to draw consumers in with low ...
Study links social media use with depression in adults
While social media has been linked to anxiety and depression in teens, a new study now suggests that adults are also susceptible. In Belgium, a ...
Nearly half a million of lives saved by COVID-19 vaccination in Europe, new study shows
A new study published on Thursday estimates that at least 470,000 lives have been saved among those aged 60 years and over since the start of ...