Phone data investigations: Belgian law could be hanging by a thread
Share article:
Share article:

Phone data investigations: Belgian law could be hanging by a thread

Eric Snoeck, director-general of the federal judicial police. © Eric Lalmand/Belga

Police, security services and other investigators will be pacing the floor in the coming month anticipating a judgement by the Constitutional Court that could, they say, undermine one of the major tools of modern crime-fighting.

The problem concerns telephone data and a Belgian law that obliges all phone service providers to keep a record of all data traffic for 12 months.

The European Court of Justice has already ruled that the Belgian law is in contravention of European law. The question now is, what will Belgium’s Constitutional Court do with that instruction?

The data concerned, supporters argue, is not a breach of privacy in that the one-year law concerns only metadata: no information about the person concerned or the content of calls, but only data about location, the duration of a call and which numbers were concerned.

Police and other services use the data extensively, for example to ping the mobile phone of a missing person, or to find out whether a given person was in a given location at a given time.

Information other than metadata – such as a caller’s identity, or the content of a call – still requires a warrant from an investigating magistrate, which in turn requires proof that a crime is being committed or is about to be committed. No question, in other words, of police carrying out a ‘fishing expedition’ in the hope of finding evidence of crime.

Related News


According to the director-general of the federal judicial police, Eric Snoeck, taking away access to phone metadata would leave the police “deaf and blind.”

But according to Xavier Van Gils, president of, the association of the French- and German-speaking bar speaking to the RTBF, the government failed to demonstrate that the utility of the power justified the “a priori surveillance of 11 million people, 24 hours a day, in order to catch a few criminals”.

The Human Rights League, meanwhile, followed that reasoning. “The method is not proportionate, even if the fight against organised crime is of course a legitimate goal.”

It was the Constitutional Court itself that sent the matter to the European Court for its opinion, and now that has been given, the final decision will rest with the Constitutional Court, due to be delivered in April.

It seems inevitable that the Court will order the law to be amended, which is a worry for Snoeck.

We are very concerned about respect for the privacy of individuals and we act in full accordance with the law, but we must retain access to a certain amount of information on a retroactive basis in order to conduct our investigations. We need to find a balance between protecting privacy and safeguarding our ability to fight crime.”

Alan Hope
The Brussels Times

Latest news

Belgian Health Minister wants pharmacists to administer vaccines
Federal Health Minister Frank Vandenbroucke has said he wants to change Belgium's law to allow pharmacists to administer Covid-19 vaccines against, ...
Ruined photos from flood victims restored for free
Much of what victims of this summer’s deadly flooding lost is irreplaceable, but when it comes to photographs that were ruined, a Brussels company is ...
New Belgian video game aims to help children who stutter
A new video game by Belgian-American start-up Say It Labs aims to teach children with a stutter various techniques to improve their speech.  ...
More than 1 in 4 Belgians use mobile phones whilst driving
A recent European study into the use of mobile phones whilst driving highlights some alarming results: 26% of Belgians read or send messages on their ...
Belgium in Brief: Memories Of Masks
Belgium's experts are concerned with the rising coronavirus figures. One possible solution could be that, once again, masks are used more widely. ...
Museum Night Fever returns to Brussels on Saturday night
After a break last year, Museum Night Fever 2021 is back again with free visits to 32 museums hosting performances, music and other events. The ...
More than €1.5 billion injected into SNCB
More than €1.5 billion in additional funding has been injected into the Belgian railways, Federal Mobility Minister Georges Gilkinet told the House ...
Non-vaccinated applicants no longer welcome at ZNA hospitals in Antwerp
The Antwerp hospital group ZNA is only taking on new employees who have been vaccinated against the coronavirus, according to reporting from VRT. ...
Pharmacies prepare to administer more rapid antigen tests
From November, anyone presenting coronavirus symptoms for less than six days will be able to take a rapid antigen test in a pharmacy, announced the ...
Chocolate, Christmas, and cocaine
Do you consider yourself a news buff? Someone constantly on top of what's going on? Then maybe you have what it takes to ace The Brussels Times ...
Introduction of Covid Safe Ticket leads more in Brussels to get vaccinated
The introduction of the Covid Safe Ticket (CST) in the Brussels-Capital Region on 15 October seems to have led to a higher number of residents ...
More and more testimonies, and a second rally against sexual violence in Brussels
A second rally against sexual violence was held in the Brussels neighbourhood of Ixelles on Thursday evening, and a sister-rally was held ...