Google listens to conversations recorded by its smart home devices
Share article:
Share article:

Google listens to conversations recorded by its smart home devices

Belgium's privacy watchdog said it will "probably" investigate Google's use of recordings stored by its smart home appliances. Credit: Pixabay

Google hires people to listen to recordings and conversations of users of the tech company’s smart home devices and applications, with some of those recordings collected without users’ consent, according to reports by VRT on Wednesday.

An anonymous subcontractor of the global tech giant gave the Flemish news site access to over a thousand conversations recorded via the Google Home smart speakers or the Google Assistant smartphone app — out of which 153 were recorded unbeknownst to the user.

That external employee was one of many hired by Google worldwide, including in Belgium, to listen back and analyze a series of recordings captured and stored by the smart assistants on Crowdsource, a platform on which anyone can help improve the company’s algorithms by describing images, audio snippets, videos…

Recordings captured by the smart devices are kept in a “hidden” area of the platform accessible only to authorised personnel, according to the outlet. The employee’s job is to “process” the recordings in order to help improve the device’s understanding of the intricacies of the human language.

“Employees must listen carefully to describe the fragment as well as possible,” the outlet writes, adding that the subcontractors are asked to describe the snipped in detail: “Can you hear a female voice, or a male voice. Is it a child? What is being said? Every cough and audible comma is written out.”

‘That is unquestionably my own voice’

The audio fragments captured and stored by the appliances are reportedly stripped of all information which may help the employee’s listening back on them to identify the persons behind them. User names and other information are stripped out of the audio files.

But a crucial part of the employee’s tasks is to help the devices make out words that it was not able to understand or process by itself, meaning “employees who listen must search every word, address, name or company name” for which the spelling is uncertain, potentially facilitating the task of completely or partially identifying the person speaking.

Some fragments that VRT listened to allowed the outlet to find and track down the users and pay them a visit in their own homes to playback the recordings for them.

“That is unquestionably my own voice,” one Flanders resident said upon listening to an audio fragment, while a couple in the town of Waasmunster said they “immediately” recognised the voices of their children and grandchildren.

Hearing problems

Most of the audio snippets the Dutch-language news site examined stemmed from users’ direct interaction with the smart appliances, resulting from the specific vocal command “Ok Google.”

According to the outlet, the smart speaker’s small print states that the recording and storing of these audio fragments is an option turned on by default — but that the fine print does not say that people will listen back on them.

But this includes only the voice recordings that are captured after the user pronounces the command “Ok Google,” yet the VRT said over a hundred fragments it was given access to were recorded unknowingly, because the smart appliances are activated by any word that “sounds like Google,” or whenever the user “accidentally pushes a button” or “unknowingly gives a command.”

The thousands of conversations analyzed by the outlet included bedroom conversations, conversations between parents and children but also “banging arguments” and “business phone conversations with a lot of confidential information.”

High tech trumps privacy

The findings of the Flemish outlet follow reports by Bloomberg in April that Amazon employees were also reviewing conversations and recordings stored by the company’s own smart home assistant, Alexa.

Like Google’s subcontractors, Amazon’s clock in the world over to listen to thousands of different recordings and conversations as a way to improve the companies’ smart appliances and beef up their algorithms, the key to their success.

In the case of Google, the company has published a series of videos aiming to fight back against concerns that it was eavesdropping.

Contacted by VRT about the recordings it obtained, the company acknowledged that it reviewed fragments to improve its technology but that it concerned only a small number of clips, which make up “only 0.2% of all audio clips.”

The company further stated that the work carried out by its subcontractors was “crucial for the development of technology that makes products such as the Google Assistant possible,” raising the question which has plagued Google, Facebook and the world’s other tech giants since they first rolled-out their high-performing products: how far can technology overstep the boundaries of privacy?

Gabriela Galindo
The Brussels Times

Latest news

More politicians than ordinary citizens at the Conference on the Future of Europe
The second Plenary of the Conference took place on Saturday in the European Parliament in Strasbourg and discussed the contributions from the ...
Belgium’s Consultative Committee to meet on Tuesday
The next meeting of Belgium's Consultative Committee, scheduled for Friday, has been brought forward to Tuesday at 4:30 PM, according to local media ...
Coca-Cola, Pepsi and Unilever are world’s biggest plastic polluters
Coca-Cola, Pepsi, and Unilever were found to be the world's biggest polluters of plastic in a report published by Branded on Monday. Over 11,000 ...
Four men charged with illegally buying thousands of live ducks to hunt on private land
Four Belgian men will appear in court on Monday facing charges related to the purchase of thousands of ducks, which were then released into a private ...
More wolf attacks: 15 deer killed at family resort over the weekend
Fifteen deer were killed by wolves in the Belgian province of Limburg this weekend, between Saturday night and Sunday morning. The deer were ...
Cost of breast cancer still too high for many patients
Breast cancer still carries too high a cost for patients when one in nine women in Belgium will face the disease before reaching 75, according to a ...
Gare Maritime: Brussels’ most exciting new architectural project
A generation ago, the Gare Maritime in the Tour & Taxis industrial site was an abandoned wasteland. It is now a model for urban renewal and ...
Belgium in Brief: Rules For A Fourth Wave
It's the news that nobody wants to hear, but here we go again. Belgium’s council of ministers will hold an emergency meeting on Monday to discuss ...
Belgian grandparents to walk across Scotland for COP26
A group of Belgian grandparents has set off on a 100 km hike that will take them from Belgium to the Scottish city of Glasgow, just ahead of the ...
Rise in fuel prices will bring Belgian State €547 million in tax, say Workers Party
The sharp rise in fuel prices that have been felt across the continent will bring an additional €547 million to the Belgian State, the Workers' Party ...
Amid backlash, Brussels police chief promises to do better for sexual assault victims
After multiple rallies against sexual violence took place in Brussels last week, with victims offering testimony of poor treatment from police when ...
Person hit by train in Brussels
A person was hit by a train in the tunnel between Brussels North and Brussels Central at around 10:20 AM on Monday, railway network manager Infrabel ...