Share article:
Share article:

Judgement expected today in King Albert II paternity case

Dephine Boël (l.) and former king Albert II. © Belga

The Cassation Court in Brussels is today expected to deliver its verdict on a case brought by the former King Albert II (photo, right), who is fighting a paternity claim by the 51-year-old artist Delphine Boël.

The court, the country’s highest tribunal against whose verdict no appeal is possible, is being asked to rule on a verdict by the Court of Appeal which ordered the former king, father of the reigning King Philippe, to obey a court order by giving a DNA sample which, Boël hopes, will prove the king is her biological father.

The Story So Far

Delphine Boël (photo, left) was born in February 1968 to aristocrat Sybille De Selys Longchamps, and recognised by her husband, industrialist Jacques Boël, as his child. However it later emerged that De Selys Longchamps had maintained a long-term relationship with the then Prince Albert, brother of the reigning King Baudouin and married to Paola Ruffo di Calabria. She claimed that her daughter had been sired by Prince Albert.

There then began a battle which has so far lasted 28 years, as Boël attempted to have her true paternity recognised by the Royal house. Contrary to the claims of critics, she declared to have no interest in claiming any of the rights of a member of the Royal family, including an allowance from the Civil List.

Albert, prince and later king on the death of his brother Baudouin, declined to comment for years, until Boël took the matter to court. There she encountered a major obstacle. Jacques Boël had officially recognised her as his child when registering her birth. By law, that makes him her legitimate father. It is possible to challenge that status in court, but there was a time limit, and Delphine had long seen it go past.

She persisted, however, the Constitutional Court overturned the law on time limits on the grounds of desuetude, allowing Delphine’s challenge to go ahead and essentially turning the case on its head.

The next step was a ruling by the Court of Appeal a year ago which recognised that her right to know her real father had primacy over Albert’s right not to be disturbed, and he was ordered to give a DNA sample to be tested to see unequivocally if he was related to Delphine.

Related News:

The Verdict

Despite more legal challenges, in the end he had no option. He gave a DNA sample, and it lies sealed, together with the results of the analysis, in the possession of the court until today’s verdict is handed down.

That will go one of two ways: either Cassation will back the Court of Appeal, in which case the matter will have to be litigated again in another court in a different judicial area; or Cassation will allow the appeal court’s ruling to stand, in which case the envelope will be opened and the results of the DNA test made known to the parties.

There is one indication of how the verdict might go. The Cassation Court’s advocate-general, whose job is to issue an advice to the judges, came down in his opinion on the side of the appeal court, advising the bench to reject the appeal of Albert II. The full court does not always follow the advice of the advocate-general, but it does so more often than not.

If it does not, then Delphine’s case ends, and Albert’s DNA sample will remain unopened for good.

Delphine does have another avenue, however. She could, in theory, bring a court action to oblige either Princess Astrid or Prince Laurent, two of the offspring of the former king, to give a DNA sample in his place. That, if the action were successful, would then be used to establish a common parent. A case concerning Albert’s first-born, King Philippe, is impossible; as reigning monarch, he is exempt from the laws of the courts.

Whether Delphine would attempt such a course of action seems unlikely. Not only would it involve a re-run of the legal circus which has surrounded this case, it also would do nothing to satisfy what she has always claimed as her reason for taking action: to be recognised by her real father. Unless he is forced to by the court today, Albert will go to his grave continuing to refuse to give her the thing she wants most.

Alan Hope
The Brussels Times

Latest news

European Council: Decisions on Covid-19 and energy and debate on other issues
At the two-days summit which ended on Friday, the European Council adopted conclusions on COVID-19, digital, energy prices, migration, trade and ...
Flanders ‘water bomb’ could cause €2 billion in damages and affect thousands
The next "water bomb" or heavy rainfall over Flanders could cause damages estimated at around €2 billion, and could affect up to 100,000 people in ...
Pfizer Covid-19 vaccine 90% effective in 5 to 11-year-olds
The Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine is 90.7% effective in preventing symptomatic forms of the coronavirus in children aged five to 11, Pfizer announced on ...
Belgian airport named best for cargo in Europe
Brussels Airport has been named the best airport in Europe in a 2021 roundup of the best cargo airports across the world. The Asian Freight, ...
NASA plans first return mission to Moon in February 2022
The United States space agency, NASA, has announced that it will be aiming to launch its first, uncrewed mission to the moon, Artemis 1, in February ...
New, reportedly more contagious Delta mutation being monitored
A new mutation of the Delta variant of the coronavirus, which is reported to be more contagious, is being monitored by health authorities in the ...
Angèle releases new single: ‘Bruxelles je t’aime’
Belgian singer Angèle has unveiled her latest song ahead of the release of her new album, due later this year. 'Bruxelles je t'aime' (Brussels I ...
23 million chickens and 1.7 million pigs: Climate experts call for livestock cut
Flander's livestock needs to be drastically cut to save the climate and reach the emission reduction targets, according to the latest advice from the ...
Vaccination uptake surges in Wallonia following CST announcement
The number of people getting vaccinated against the coronavirus increased fourfold in Wallonia after it was announced that the Covid Safe Ticket ...
Guilty by association
BRUSSELS BEHIND THE SCENES Weekly analysis and untold stories With SAM MORGAN Other Brussels behind the scenes stories: Brussels' bid to make ...
Health minister supports use of Covid Safe Ticket in workplace
As the use of the Covid Safe Ticket (CST) has been expanded in Brussels and is set to in Wallonia, federal health minister Frank Vandenbroucke has ...
Maggots show Conings may have lived longer following disappearance
Former army soldier Jürgen Conings, whose disappearance in mid-May resulted in a month-long manhunt, may have been alive for longer than has been ...