Share article:
Share article:

EU announces new strategy on migrants’ voluntary return

Margaritis Schinas, Vice-President of the European Commission, and Ylva Johansson, European Commissioner, on the EU Strategy on sustainable voluntary return and reintegration, at the press conference on 27 April, Credit: EU

The European Commission has adopted a new strategy on voluntary return and reintegration of migrants and asylum seekers with no right to stay in the EU as a part of a common EU system.

The new strategy is described as a key objective under the so-called pact on migration and asylum which was presented by the Commission in September last year. Currently, only about a third of people with no right to stay in the EU return to their country of origin and of those who do, fewer than 30% do so voluntarily.

Voluntary return is the assisted or independent return of a person who does not have the right to stay in the EU to their country of origin or transit, based on their own free will. To encourage and facilitate voluntary returns, member states may offer to assist the returnee, for example by covering the travel expenses and providing help, in cash or in-kind, for a short period upon arrival.

People with no right to stay are generally given a period for voluntary departure during which they should return voluntarily in compliance with a return decision. This period normally varies between 7 and 30 days. During this period, the authorities may not enforce the decision unless they identify a risk of absconding or security risks.

“Voluntary returns are always the better option: they put the individual at the core, they are more effective and less costly,” said Ylva Johansson, Commissioner for Home Affairs, at a press briefing last week (27 April).

Margaritis Schinas Vice-President for Promoting our European Way of Life, was frank at the briefing and admitted that the return policy until now has been a failure. The low return rate from the EU is a result of several factors including fragmented and inefficient procedures within the EU as well as low levels of cooperation of countries outside the EU on identification and readmission of returnees.

The system needs to be fixed and the new strategy for voluntary returns and reintegration sets out measures to strengthen the legal and operational framework and improve the quality of return and reintegration programs.

Enhanced role for Frontex in returns

Among others Frontex, the European Border and Coast Guard Agency will get an enhanced mandate to increase its capacity to support member states in all stages of the voluntary return and reintegration process. Frontex has been accused of illegal pushbacks of migrants but Johansson expressed her full trust in the agency after it has been cleared in an internal investigation.

“We don’t accept any cheap bashing of Frontex,” she said and assured that the agency will have the resources to carry out its tasks, including returns. The agency started supporting member states in the area of voluntary returns in 2020. Around 18% of its return operations organised were voluntary returns, and this share is increasing.

“We need to do everything to save lives,” she underlined and referred to the tragedies in the Mediterranean Sea when illegal migrants have drowned trying to reach EU shores in overcrowded unworthy vessels lured by traffickers.

A return Coordinator and High-Level Network for Return, comprising representatives from member states, will be established to provide further technical support to the Member States to bring more coherence between different policies that affect the effectiveness of return policies,

Asked about the recent Danish decision to revoke residency permits for Syrian refugees, she replied that it concerns her. “Nobody can be forced to return to Syria,” she said.  She had talked to the Danish authorities which assured her that they will respect the principle of non-refoulment. However, she added that Denmark has opted out of the EU acquis on migration.

No agreement on EU list of safe countries

The non-refoulment principle guarantees that no one should be returned to a country where they would face torture, cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment, and other irreparable harm. Even if that would not be the case in Syria today, refugees that left the country are seen as enemies by the regime and are likely to be denied access to their former homes and any government assistance.

The Commission considers that if someone’s asylum claim is rejected today, it is because that the applicant can safely return to his/her country, based on an individual assessment. Currently, there is no common EU list of safe third countries and countries of origin and the new pact called for a higher degree of harmonisation through EU lists.

Commissioner Johansson did not address the issue of a common EU list and stressed that every member state must make an individual assessment in each return case, where the personal situation is examined and the principle of non-refoulment is upheld.

The European Asylum Support Office publishes guidance on countries of origin. Member state authorities are responsible for making the return decisions which until now has resulted in a non-uniform application of the return policy. Under the Return Directive, the decisions are subject to a remedy before a court.

In 2016, the Commission proposed a safe country list in the Asylum Procedure Regulation. Under the proposal, all asylum applications from nationals of a country on the safe country list would still continue to be assessed on an individual, case-by-case basis.

Strong safeguards, including the right to appeal, would remain in place. A European list would however allow for swifter processing of individual asylum applications from candidates originating from countries considered to be safe, and for faster returns if, following an individual assessment of the application, the claim for asylum is rejected.

However, during the last round of negotiations, the Council did not agree on a position on a common European list of safe countries of origin as proposed by the Commission.

M. Apelblat
The Brussels Times

Latest news

Health minister supports use of Covid Safe Ticket in workplace
As the use of the Covid Safe Ticket (CST) has been expanded in Brussels and is set to in Wallonia, federal health minister Frank Vandenbroucke has ...
Maggots show Conings may have lived longer following disappearance
Former army soldier Jürgen Conings, whose disappearance in mid-May resulted in a month-long manhunt, may have been alive for longer than has been ...
Pandora Papers: European Parliament describes UK and US as global hubs for money laundering and tax evasion
The European Parliament adopted on Thursday a resolution taking the European Commission to task for not doing enough to combat money laundering, tax ...
Museum Night Fever returns to Brussels on Saturday night
After a break last year, Museum Night Fever 2021 is back again with free visits to 29 museums hosting performances, music and other events. The ...
More than 100 people hospitalised with coronavirus per day
More than 100 people are being hospitalised per day in Belgium as a result of the coronavirus, as the rise in new Covid-19 infections continues its ...
Digital well-being: being healthy in a hyperconnected world
There was hardly any doubt about the direction that digital innovation was moving in, but whilst the pandemic restricted human contact and slowed ...
Belgian Health Minister wants pharmacists to administer vaccines
Federal Health Minister Frank Vandenbroucke has said he wants to change Belgium's law to allow pharmacists to administer Covid-19 vaccines against, ...
Ruined photos from flood victims restored for free
Much of what victims of this summer’s deadly flooding lost is irreplaceable, but when it comes to photographs that were ruined, a Brussels company is ...
New Belgian video game aims to help children who stutter
A new video game by Belgian-American start-up Say It Labs aims to teach children with a stutter various techniques to improve their speech.  ...
More than 1 in 4 Belgians use mobile phones whilst driving
A recent European study into the use of mobile phones whilst driving highlights some alarming results: 26% of Belgians read or send messages on their ...
Belgium in Brief: Memories Of Masks
Belgium's experts are concerned with the rising coronavirus figures. One possible solution could be that, once again, masks are used more widely. ...
More than €1.5 billion injected into SNCB
More than €1.5 billion in additional funding has been injected into the Belgian railways, Federal Mobility Minister Georges Gilkinet told the House ...