European Commission defends compulsory licences over patent removal
Share article:
Share article:

European Commission defends compulsory licences over patent removal

Credit: Belga

The European Commission defended using compulsory licences rather than lifting patents on Covid-19 vaccines on Wednesday, calling the United States’ stance in favour of the latter “a nice media stunt.”

“Whatever respect one may have for [US President] Joe Biden, this announcement on the lifting of patents is just a nice media stunt, given that the United States exports almost no vaccines or vaccine components,” said Frédérique Ries (MR, Renew Europe).

Ries called for encouraging knowledge sharing and technology transfer, as well as the establishment of production facilities, especially in Africa.

“Compulsory licences are a perfectly legitimate tool in the context of a pandemic,” said Commission Vice-President Valdis Dombrovskis, in charge of trade, during a debate in the European Parliament on lifting patents.

Dombrovskis argued that licences can support increased vaccine production and knowledge sharing.

A compulsory licence allows public authorities to take away a patent holder’s choice to refuse to license his or her invention in certain cases – and public health is one of them. This imposition is then accompanied by financial compensation for the patent holder.

Dombrovskis has announced that a proposal to this effect will be submitted to the World Trade Organisation (WTO) in July.

Other proposed solutions could also include limiting export restrictions (the US and UK are targeted with this, though not named directly), increasing production and producer commitments, investing in production capacity in developing countries and increasing contributions to the Covax programme, which aims to ensure equitable access to vaccination in 200 countries.

The vast majority of MEPs criticised the US and UK for piling up excessive doses while poorer countries have little or no access to them.

But on the idea of a temporary waiver of patent rights (IPR), MEPs were divided.

Commission President Ursula von der Leyen said that in the short and medium term, lifting patents would not provide an extra dose of vaccine.

“The EU can be proud of exporting 50% of its vaccine production, but it would be shocking and undignified to continue to see it block the suspension of patents at international level, which would allow a rapid increase in production,” said Greens/EFA co-chair Philippe Lamberts (Ecolo).

Lamberts stressed that pharmaceutical factories exist all over the world, and said he had fears regarding the EU’s desire to “preserve the profit margins of big pharma rather than human life.”

On the other hand, Geert Bourgeois (N-VA, CRE group) saw it as a “false good idea” that would not speed up the supply of vaccines and would harm innovation.

Bourgeois stressed that intellectual property rights were the result of intensive, time-consuming and costly research, guaranteeing tens of thousands of jobs.

He advocated increased production and the need for the Commission to enter into agreements with developing countries to export vaccines and provide human and logistical support for vaccination.

The Brussels Times

Latest news

European Parliament wants to sue the Commission for delaying rule of law conditionality
In a rare move on Thursday, the Legal Affairs Committee of the European Parliament voted for the Parliament to take the European Commission to court ...
Mayor wants to close two Brussels bars where alleged sexual assaults took place
Ixelles' Mayor Christos Doulkeridis (Ecolo) said that he’d like to close the two bars that employed a man accused of raping multiple patrons, ...
‘Untenable’: Mayor says situation at Brussels North station is out of control
The situation at Brussels North Station is no longer tenable, Schaerbeek's mayor Cécile Jodogne (Défi) says. Drug dealing, homelessness, ...
Suicide second-leading cause of death among European youth
Suicide is the number two killer among young people living in Europe, a recent Unicef report on the state of their mental health found. The ...
‘Too little, too late’: Brussels mayors criticise CST implementation
After a two week delay, the Covid Safe Ticket (CST) will become mandatory in several situations in Brussels from today (Friday). Some mayors blame a ...
Sciensano expert warns of rising Covid-19 cases this winter
The return of colder weather and the relaxing of health measures are giving rise to new Covid-19 contaminations and hospitalisations around Belgium, ...
Hospital food is making you sick, Belgian study shows
Eating hospital meals results in a measurable decline in health, according to a report from the Flemish television network VTM, which paints a ...
Belgium in Brief: Supply Issues
There are few things more jarring than walking into a store and finding that the shelves are empty, be that partially or otherwise. One thing ...
Stolen Magritte painting on display for first time in ten years
Surrealist painter René Magritte's work "Olympia", which made headlines across the world when it was stolen from a museum in Belgium in 2009, will be ...
Brussels airport pilots ’15 minute’ PCR test
Brussels Airport has announced that it will soon begin a trial of an ultra-fast PCR test able to detect Covid-19 in 15 minutes, a far faster ...
Over 1,000 demonstrators march in Brussels following sexual assault allegations
Around 1,300 people gathered in Ixelles on Thursday night to march against sexual violence, according to reporting from Bruzz. The march was ...
Covid Safe Ticket mandatory in Brussels, but no fines yet
The Brussels-Capital Region will expand the use of the Covid Safe Ticket (CST) from today (Friday), but it will take a few days before rule-breakers ...