Curfews and travel ban violate fundamental rights, warns Belgian law professor
Share article:
Share article:

Curfews and travel ban violate fundamental rights, warns Belgian law professor

Credit: Belga

The curfew and the non-essential travel ban imposed by the Belgian government are resulting in the systematic ignoring of constitutional freedoms that are meant to protect citizens, according to a constitutional law professor.

Pressure has further mounted against the government regarding these coronavirus fighting measures after both were extended during Friday’s Consultative Committee.

“Even when fighting a pandemic, the constitutional freedom rules must be respected. The government should instead be looking for alternatives to those measures that are in conflict with the constitution,” Professor of constitutional law Hendrik Vuye (University of Namur) told De Tijd.

He added: “I am sorry to say, but the Council of State is not playing its role. Instead of controlling the government, it is simply an extension of the Ministry of the Interior.”

Related News

 

The curfew, from 10:00 PM until 6:00 in Brussels, and between midnight and 5:00 AM in Flanders and Wallonia, prevents certain freedoms which are written in the Constitution, such as the freedoms of worship and association, making these preventative measures constitutionally difficult.

Fundamental rights can only be restricted when it is necessary for a democracy, Vuye explained. In the case of imposing a curfew to avoid corona parties, for example, “this can also be prevented with a ban on gathering, which is a less far-reaching intervention.”

Under the Belgian Constitution, it is stated that its rules cannot be suspended either in whole or in part, resulting in politicians, including MR president Georges-Louis Bouchez and minister-president of Flanders Jan Jambon saying it is a fundamental restriction of freedoms.

Meanwhile, the Flemish right-wing N-VA party submitted a bill to abolish the measure, emphasising the fact that there was no parliamentary debate about it and its extension.

Freedom of movement

When first imposed in January, the non-essential travel ban was expected to prohibit all travel in and out of the country for a “recreational or touristic purpose” until March, but this has been extended until 18 April, the end of the Easter holidays.

This travel ban was criticised by the European Commission, which gave Belgium ten days to justify it, to which the federal government responded saying Belgium’s current ban on non-essential travel is proportionate and will remain in place.

Several politicians, including Justice Commissioner Didier Reynders, have argued that this measure too imposes on fundamental rights, mainly the freedom of movement.

Vuye also highlighted that, normally, the government cannot deny people access to their property, adding that “the regulations should at least be adjusted so that people with a second residence can go there.”

In the meantime, Belgium’s core cabinet of ministers approved the preliminary draft of the so-called pandemic law.

“Fighting a pandemic often requires far-reaching measures,” Prime Minister Alexander De Croo said in a press release, stressing that the democratic basis for them has to be as strong as possible.

Lauren Walker
The Brussels Times

Latest news

Consultative Committee will announce latest measures from 6:30 PM
The Consultative Committee will announce the latest changes to Belgium’s coronavirus restrictions in a press conference at 6:30 PM on Tuesday, ...
Belgium intends to activate the pandemic law, says Health Minister
"We intend to activate the pandemic law," Public Health Minister Frank Vandenbroucke confirmed on Tuesday in the House committee, ahead of Tuesday's ...
Offers for fake Covid Safe Tickets circulating on social media
As the Covid Safe Ticket (CST) becomes mandatory in many places across Belgium, offers for forgeries are increasingly circulating on social media. ...
EU auditors: More worried about the future budget than about pervasive errors in the 2020 budget
The European Court of Auditors (ECA) have signed off the 2020 EU accounts as giving a true and fair view of the union’s financial position but like ...
Belgium aims to tackle sexual violence with video interrogations
The federal government is looking to tackle sexual violence and increase convictions connected to this crime by relying more heavily on video ...
Duvel celebrates 150th anniversary with special brew in commemorative bottle
Belgium’s Duvel Moortgat Brewery is celebrating its 150th anniversary with the release of a special brew in a commemorative bottle shaped like its ...
Pollution scandal: 3M to show emissions don’t pose risk or halt production
Flanders has ordered American company 3M, involved in a pollution scandal in Antwerp, to prove that emissions linked to its production activities do ...
The Netherlands fears a greater rise in sea levels than forecast
Sea levels could rise by up to two metres by 2100 on the Dutch coastline – far more than previously forecast – according to an announcement from the ...
The Smurfs return to Belgian TV with the first new show since 1989
A new Smurfs show is bringing the characters of Belgium's second-most-famous comic franchise back to the small screen with their first new series, 30 ...
On this day in Brussels: An entrepreneurial journey begins
The Rue Dansaert was just beginning to become trendy when Alain Coumont opened his first bakery here on 26 October 1990. He started by baking big ...
Almost half of Belgian subsidies from EU left unused
Belgium left almost half (49%) of its subsidies allocated by the European Union between 2013 and 2020 unused, the equivalent of around €1.375 ...
Visitors to embark on Orient Express adventure at Brussels exhibition
An exhibition dedicated to the Orient Express – the train that was the scene for many novels, including Agatha Christie's – allows visitors to ...